Last week, Universal Music Group boss Sir Lucian Graingecalled out “bad actors” for using illegitimate means to suck royalty revenue from music streaming services; Grainge argued that these platforms’ dominant ‘pro rata’ payout model needed to change.
Yesterday (January 17), MBW carried the words of Nick Dunn, CEO of indie distributor Horus Music, who applauded Grainge’s letter – whilst dropping the bombshell that his company had seen evidence of streaming fraud being carried out by “criminal gangs”, who had even issued death threats to his staff for blocking their practices.
What this narrative has been missing, however, is firm, industry-verified data on how pervasive (and expensive) the issue of streaming fraud is for the music business.
That just changed.
France’s Centre National de Musique (CNM) is a public body in the country, and operates under the supervision of the Ministry of Culture and Communication.
You may remember the CNM for its in-depth investigation into the effects of user-centric (or ‘fan-powered’) music streaming licensing in 2021.
This week, the CNM released the results of another landmark study into France’s music industry – this time focusing on illegitimate streaming practices.
The conclusion? At least 1%-3% of music streams in the country are fraudulent. i.e. They are generated, often via paid-for stream farms, by those “bad actors” in a bid to siphon royalty money away from legitimate artists.
The CNM says that its new study considered a vast set of data provided by Spotify, Deezer, and Qobuz, plus data provided by “a panel of distributors” (including Universal, Sony, Warner, Believe and Wagram).
Music distributed by these companies, says the CNM, represented more than 90% of the top 10,000 most listened-to titles on Spotify, and more than 75% of the overall volume of streams on Deezer, in the relevant period.
According to the CNM report, in France, between 1billion and 3 billion streams “at least” were discovered to be “false” in 2021. Neatly enough, those figures were approximately the equivalent of between 1% and 3% of total plays in the market that year.
If we apply this 1-3% threshold to wider industry value figures, the momentous size of the streaming fraud problem becomes clear.
The French music market in 2021 generated EUR €492 million (USD $581.5m) in streaming revenues annually according to French music body SNEP.
One percent of that figure would be €4.92 million ($5.8m). Three percent would be €14.76 million ($17.4m).
And if we apply the same figures globally?
The worldwide trade revenues of music streaming platforms (including both paid subscription and advertising-supported) in 2021, was $16.9 billionaccording to the IFPI.
One percent of that would be $169 million.
Three percent would be $507 million. i.e over half a billion dollars.
The real problem may be much bigger than 3% of streams, notes the CNM, because it says that its report relied only “on fraudulent streams detected by the platforms and eliminated from the sharing of [royalties]”.
In other words: they only counted the fraudsters who didn’t get away with it.
The CNM adds that it is “certain that the reality of false streams goes beyond what is detected, without it being possible to arrive at a precise figure… since they do not fall within the scope of detection”.
In addition, the body has called out Amazon Music, YouTube and Apple Music for declining to participate / supply data for the study.
The CNM says that these platforms were “unable or unwilling to share their data according to the defined observation perimeter, despite all the guarantees of confidentiality that the CNM provided them”.
The CNM reports that hip-hop/rap music represented 84.5% of fraudulent streams detected amid Spotify’s top 10,000 tracks during 2021.
To a degree, this is to be expected: hip-hop is the dominant genre in the French market (accounting for more than 50% of the top 10,000 tracks on Spotify and 40% on Deezer, according to the report).
The CNM explains further however, that compared to the total number of streams generated by hip-hop and rap in 2021, fraudulent streams represented a small share of the genre’s total listens, with a 0.4% share on Spotify and 0.7% on Deezer.
The study claims that the market share of streams detected as fraudulent on total plays of other specific genres was significantly higher for the likes of background music (4.8% on Deezer) and ‘non-musical titles’ (3.5%).
“The possible distrust of users in the face of systems that leave room for cheating is a risk that should not be underestimated.”
Jean-Philippe Thiellay, National Music Center
In the announcement of the CNM report issued this week, Jean-Philippe Thiellay, President of the music org, said (translated): “In a context where the rate of penetration of [music streaming] services in French households still has room for improvement in comparison with our [UK], German or even American neighbours… the possible distrust of users in the face of systems that leave room for cheating is a risk that should not be underestimated.”
Added Thiellay: “Finally, for the artists themselves… fraudulent streams disrupt algorithmic profiles and weaken engagement rates… since, of course, fake users don’t behave like regular fans.”
Thiellay noted that “well known” mechanisms used to generate fraudulent streams included “false plays exceeding the counting threshold of 30 seconds operated by robots or natural persons, [as well as] false playlists, [and illegitimate] additions of titles on the platforms”.
He continued: “Stream farms, hacking of accounts… the imagination of pirates is rich and evolving, to the point that the countermeasures implemented by the platforms [and] the distributors and rightsholders of music, must not only constantly evolve and improve, but also anticipate any counter-offensive from fraudsters.”
“Now that the industry is growing again — in large part as a result of UMG’s strategy, investments and innovation — new players as well as some bad actors who do not share our commitment to artists and artistry have been swooping into the reinvigorated industry.”
Sir Lucian Grainge, Universal Music Group (writing in a New Year note to staff)
Writing in a New Year note to staff last week, Sir Lucian Grainge, Chairman and CEO of Universal Music Group said: “Now that the industry is growing again — in large part as a result of UMG’s strategy, investments and innovation — new players as well as some bad actors who do not share our commitment to artists and artistry have been swooping into the reinvigorated industry.
Added Grainge: “In the past, music industry conflict was often focused on ‘the majors versus the indies.’ Today, however, the real divide is between those committed to investing in artists and artist development versus those committed to gaming the system through quantity over quality.
“The current environment has attracted players who see an economic opportunity in flooding platforms with all sorts of irrelevant content that deprives both artists and labels from the compensation they deserve.”
Note: EUR-USD currency conversions in this story are based on the IRS’s published annual average exchange rates.Music Business Worldwide
